outlining a promise

a promise-progress-payoff loop can be anything:

  • a part of a scene
  • a scene
  • a sequence
  • a whole arc

promise

you must promise it.

  • make the character realize they have a goal, and show that to the reader. and the reader will automatically be promised it.

show, dont tell the promise.

ex:

promising that he’ll get revenge

  • showing (good): digging through his storage, finding a crate, opening it and revealing guns.
  • telling (bad): “i’ll get my revenge,” he thought

progress

the conflict should be:

the harder it is, the more struggle there is, generally the better. there should be obstacles. because then it feels more earned.

  • it should have been hard-fought
    • the more difficulty, the more conflict, the more tension that was required to get to the payoff, the more impactful it is
    • before succeeding at something, generally the character should fail 1-3 times. and the things they try should be the most intelligent things they could have done

the way progress is shown

(i think) it’s better to show lots of 1% progress, instead of few 25% progress.

  • does this progress feel substantial

  • is the way the progress shown unique

  • what are your sources of tension?

  • extend tension as long as possible in stories

  • delay resolution, but tease it.

    • drop near-reveals, partial answers, or obstacles that prevent the reveal.
  • dont delay too long without showing progress/change.

progress should ideally show the moment change happens

show that the outcome of that progress is there to stay. that something has substantially changed. in other words, that the progress actually mattered.

show backward progress too.

payoff

  • it must lead to change in the story

    • ex: the emperor is killed. now the country is in chaos, and people are vying for power.
  • should be surprising yet inevitable

    • one thing you can do is make them believe it wont happen
  • to do “stand up and cheer” moments is when you fulfill the internal (character) arcs right before external plot arcs. this is usually always the structure you want

  • if you have many plotlines, dont overlap the payoffs too much (dont have them all go off at the same time). this would make the reader get a numbness to the aewsome happening aorun dthem. instead you should stagger them.